Cloud Backup vs. On-Premises Backup: Which Should You Choose?

November 14, 2025

Data is the lifeblood of modern businesses. Losing it, even for a few hours, can lead to financial loss, reputational damage, and operational chaos. That’s why having a robust backup strategy is essential. But when it comes to choosing between cloud backup and on-premises backup, the decision isn’t always straightforward.

Both options have their advantages and drawbacks. In this blog, we’ll explore what each solution offers, compare them across cost, security, scalability, and performance, and help you decide which is right for your business. Plus, we’ll show how Indiko Data can help you build a strategy that fits your needs.


What Is Cloud Backup?

Cloud backup involves storing your data on remote servers managed by a third-party provider. Your files are encrypted and transmitted securely over the internet to data centres, where they are maintained and monitored.

This approach has become increasingly popular because it offers flexibility and convenience. Businesses can back up data without investing in expensive hardware, and recovery can happen from anywhere with an internet connection.

However, cloud backup isn’t perfect. It relies on your internet bandwidth, which means large-scale restores can take time. There are also compliance considerations, especially if your industry requires data to remain within specific geographic boundaries.


What Is On-Premises Backup?

On-premises backup stores data locally on servers or appliances within your organisation’s physical location. This traditional approach gives businesses complete control over their data and infrastructure.


The biggest advantage? Speed. Restoring data from local servers is typically faster than downloading it from the cloud. It’s also easier to meet strict compliance requirements because you know exactly where your data resides.


But on-premises backup comes with challenges. Hardware costs can be significant, and scaling up means buying and installing more equipment. There’s also the risk of physical damage, fire, flood, or theft could compromise your backups if they’re not properly protected.


Cloud vs. On-Premises: A Comparison

Cost Considerations

For many businesses, cost is the deciding factor. Cloud backup offers a subscription-based model, which means predictable monthly fees and minimal upfront investment. On-premises solutions, on the other hand, require significant capital expenditure for hardware, software, and ongoing maintenance. This can make on-premises solutions appear to be less expensive, as the annual operating costs are absorbed into utility bills and staffing, etc. However, on-premises systems need to be incrementally scaled every year or two, which normally incurs significant cost and disruption.


Security Factors

Both options can be secure if implemented correctly. Cloud providers typically offer advanced encryption, multi-factor authentication, and 24/7 monitoring. On-premises solutions give you full control, but that also means you’re responsible for physical security and disaster-proofing.


Scalability and Performance

Cloud backup wins on scalability. Need more storage? It’s just a click away. On-premises solutions require purchasing and installing new hardware, which can be time-consuming and costly. However, when it comes to restoring speed, on-premises often has the edge, especially for large datasets.


Which Should You Choose?

The right choice depends on your priorities:


  • Choose Cloud Backup if: You want flexibility, lower upfront costs, and remote accessibility.
  • Choose On-Premises if: You need full control, ultra-fast restores, and have strict compliance requirements.


The Hybrid Approach: Best of Both Worlds

Increasingly, businesses are adopting hybrid backup strategies, combining cloud and on-premises solutions. This approach offers the convenience and scalability of the cloud, plus the speed and control of local backups. It’s a smart way to build resilience without compromise.


Don’t forget to test your system!

A common failure of backup planning is that when you need to use it most, it doesn’t work the way you expect. This could be for an array of reasons, such as presumed knowledge (poorly documented processes) or technology drift, meaning that documented processes are no longer accurate. You should aim to test backup and restore at least once per year. And not just test that it works, but test that it follows your documentation. Cloud backup systems often have a built-in testing facility that makes this task easier.


A final note about Business Continuity

Business Continuity is a separate but related topic and something to keep in mind when planning your backup strategy. Business Continuity differs from Disaster Recovery by looking at organisational resilience, not just technological resilience. Having a backup and recovery system is important, but what if a pandemic led to your IT staff being ill and unable to restore your data - who would do this for you? Or a terrorist incident damaging your offices and equipment so you had no system capacity to restore into? This is a big topic in its own right and something we will address in a future post. In short, make sure your backup strategy takes into account the need for people and process, and ensure you have resilience in your backup plans.


How Indiko Data Can Help

At Indiko Data, we specialise in designing backup strategies that fit your business, not the other way around. Whether you choose cloud, on-premises, or a hybrid solution, we ensure your data is secure, compliant, and always recoverable.


Ready to protect your business?
Contact Indiko Data today
to discuss your backup strategy.

Machine cogs with the words 'Regulations' and 'Compliance'
October 30, 2025
In today’s digital world, compliance isn’t optional — it’s essential. Compliance done right isn’t just a legal safeguard; it’s a competitive advantage.
Close-up image of a person using a laptop. The screen is projecting pink and purple hues.
October 29, 2025
Cybersecurity Awareness Month is a great time to spotlight a truth many businesses overlook: your biggest cybersecurity risk isn’t a piece of software — it’s human error.
A light-up keyboard with the words Data Backup on the enter key.
October 17, 2025
Backups alone won’t protect your business. Discover why cyber resilience and integrated protection are essential to defend against modern threats.
Visual showing hacker installing a ransomware hack on laptop and phone screen.
October 8, 2025
Ransomware is rising fast. Learn how UK small businesses can build resilience with secure backups, smart protection, and expert recovery support.
Illustration showing five layers of cybersecurity protection: backup, anti-malware, patching, email
October 1, 2025
Antivirus alone isn’t enough in 2025. Discover the five essential layers of cyber protection you need to stay secure: backup, anti-malware, patching, email security, and endpoint detection.
September 30, 2025
Partnering to stay secure, efficient and competitive in today’s digital landscape. Nowadays, SMBs must prioritize cybersecurity, data management, productivity and network infrastructure. Leveraging an experienced Managed Service Provider (MSP) can help protect, optimize and grow your business by offering cost savings, expertise, improved security and streamlined processes. Here’s the key services to help SMBs (like yours!) build a strong and resilient IT foundation, ensuring operational efficiency and data security in the modern business environment.
September 30, 2025
A Comprehensive Guide Cybercriminals are becoming more sophisticated, and businesses of all sizes are at risk. Whether it’s phishing emails designed to steal login credentials, ransomware attacks that lock you out of your data, or vulnerabilities in connected devices, cyberthreats have devastating consequences. Understanding these threats and taking proactive steps to protect your business can help avoid costly breaches, downtime and reputational damage. 
Indiko Data team showcasing proactive security tools and tactics inspired by Black Hat 2025 insights
August 13, 2025
Black Hat 2025 proved that reactive security is obsolete. Indiko Data turns insights into action with AI defence and expert-led, proactive protection.
A collage of photos from Acronis Partner Day 2025
July 29, 2025
Discover key insights from Acronis Partner Day South Africa 2025—from faster backups to AI-driven security and Warm DR in Azure.
July 10, 2025
BackUp and Disaster Recovery (DR) are often mistaken for one another, or combined without providing any form of differentiation, but do you know what the difference between the two of them is? In straightforward terms, BackUp is the process of making the file copies. Whilst DR is the plan and processes used for the copies to quickly restore access to applications, data and IT resources after an outage. Think of it this way, if you just have copies of the data, it doesn’t mean much if your service isn’t available for your customers, you must also ensure business continuity. To do this you need a robust, and tested, backup and disaster recovery plan. 3-2-1 BackUp Strategy Data backup involves making copies of your data from their original sources and adding them to different locations. One backup copy is not enough. For example, if you backup your computer to an external hard drive you keep in your office, and there was a fire in the office, you would lose both your computer and the external drive. The 3-2-1 backup strategy rule removes this risk. Doubling the protection of your data by keeping backup copies locally, off-site and on external storage devices. 3. Create three copies of data, the original and two copies 2. Store data on different media storage types 1. Keep one backup copy in a separate geographic location. Whilst the 3-2-1 rule is important, you must also determine a timetable to backup your system on a regular basis. Establish a frequent backup schedule, this should be determined based on how much data you are willing to use. Most people back up on a daily or weekly basis. But you don’t have to remember to do this manually, you can use software which automatically manages this for you. Who said money can’t buy peace of mind? Disaster Recovery plan Normal business operations after a downtime or data loss incident can take days or weeks to resume. Can you afford to wait before resuming service? Will your customers understand and stick around? Or will they move their business to a competitor with a strong disaster recovery program? You need a disaster recovery plan which will provide you with immediate access to your data, enabling you to resume services as quickly as possible. With the use of cloud-based disaster recovery services this is now much easier to manage, as well as more affordable, even for smaller businesses. But what do you need to consider when building a DR plan? Perform a business impact analysis (BIA) – This will help you determine the scope of potential aftereffects and impacts in case of disruption to the business Perform risk analysis and vulnerability assessments – Anticipate and plan for the worst case scenario Identify roles and responsibilities – Define the recovery teams roles and responsibilities in the event of a disaster Take inventory – Look at your IT infrastructure, including hardware, software, applications and critical data so you can prioritise the most essential systems and assets Communication plan – Confirm who and when you will report any incidents, keeping in mind local compliance and regulatory laws Recovery Time Objective (RTO) and Recovery Point Objective (RPO) – Determine how long your business can manage with an interruption to normal operations, and how much data you can stand to lose (typically measured in time, days, hours, minutes) Build and test your plan Now you understand the difference between backup and disaster recovery, and why you need both. But you shouldn’t just implement these solutions and step back. You need to create an incident response plan which should include: Names and numbers of core internal and external contacts in hard copy form A reliable fallback internal communications channel in the event you cannot access email Documented communications plan which highlights who need to be contacted and by whom. You should review and test this plan regularly to check for any gaps or problems. Conclusion It’s not so much a case of if an attack will happen to your business, but more of a case of when. The latest surge of cyberthreats attacks has increased the average cost of a data breach from $4.55 million per incident to $5.53 million according to IBM’s Cost of a Data Breach 2024 report. You need to plan for the probability that an attack will happen and build the defences to ensure your business continues in the aftermath of data loss and/or downtime. If you are planning how you can reduce the threat of data loss and downtime to your business let’s talk ! We’re happy to help.